13 Most Expensive Yogurt In The Us

While some types cost a lot, yogurt has always been seen as a tasty and healthy snack. There are many affordable brands at the store, but some yogurts are made for people who want something special. These are meant for those who love good food and care about their health. They use top-quality ingredients and are crafted with great care. This kind of yogurt isn’t just about health; it also brings a touch of luxury to your everyday snack, making it popular with both food lovers and health-conscious people.

High-end yogurts in the US are made using the best methods and ingredients. They often start with organic or grass-fed milk. Many are full of healthy probiotics and are made in small batches by hand. Some brands add rare fruits or superfoods and use eco-friendly packaging. These extra touches add to the flavor and cost. But people are willing to pay more for yogurt that not only tastes great but is also better for the environment and made with care. These factors make premium yogurt stand out on the shelves.

This guide will show you some of the most luxurious yogurt brands in the US. Whether you’re a foodie looking for something rich and creamy or just wondering why some yogurt is so pricey, this list has something for you. These yogurts are special because of how they’re made, what they contain, and the care put into every container. You’ll learn what makes them different and why people choose to spend more on them. Let’s explore these indulgent options and find out what makes them worth the extra cost.

1. White Moustache Yogurt—Persian Style Luxury

White Moustache Yogurt is a high-end brand known for using traditional Persian recipes and handmade methods. They use premium milk from small family farms and make their yogurt in small batches. Each jar costs between $6 and $9 and contains no fake flavors, preservatives, or thickeners.

The result is a smooth, rich texture that stands out. Some jars come with honey or sweet fruit compotes, and they also offer probiotic whey drinks and date-flavored yogurt. Their eco-friendly packaging adds to their charm, making them popular in upscale grocery stores across the US.

2. Noosa Finest Yoghurt—Aussie-Inspired Creaminess

Noosa Yoghurt began in Colorado but takes its inspiration from Australian yogurt styles. It’s known for its creamy, thick texture and rich, sweet flavors. Each 8-ounce cup costs between $2.50 and $4.00, making it a bit pricier than everyday brands.

Noosa uses whole milk and lets the yogurt ferment slowly for better taste. They use real fruit in flavors like Passion Fruit, Raspberry Habanero, and Lemon. The ingredients are non-GMO, and the packaging is recyclable. It’s perfect for people who want a tasty snack that also feels like a treat.

3. Bellwether Farms Sheep Milk Yogurt

Bellwether Farms makes yogurt from sheep’s milk, which has more protein and nutrients than cow’s milk. A single-serving cup costs around $3.50 to $5.00. It has a smooth texture and a mild tangy flavor. The milk comes from pasture-raised sheep in Northern California, and the company uses ethical farming practices.

It’s a great option for people who want a rich, creamy yogurt or who are sensitive to lactose. Popular flavors include strawberry, vanilla, and blackberry, though many enjoy the plain variety for its natural taste. The brand has a clean look and a gourmet appeal.

4. Siggi’s Icelandic-Style Skyr

Siggi’s is well-known for making skyr, a thick and protein-rich yogurt from Iceland. A single cup costs between $1.79 and $2.29, though the price rises for larger tubs or rare flavors. This yogurt uses only natural ingredients and avoids fake sweeteners and colors.

Each cup takes several cups of milk to make due to the straining process. Fitness fans love it for its low sugar and high protein. Siggi’s offers special flavors like Vanilla & Cinnamon and Acai Berry. While it’s sold in large stores, its quality and unique taste give it a boutique feel.

5. Dreaming Cow Cream Top Yogurt

Dreaming Cow makes yogurt with grass-fed milk and leaves it non-homogenized so that a layer of cream rises to the top. Each 5.3-ounce cup costs around $2.00 to $2.50. The cows graze on open pastures, making the milk richer and more flavorful. The brand uses sustainable farming and cares about animal welfare.

Their yogurts use real fruit and include creative flavors like Dark Cherry Chai and Blueberry Cardamom. Dreaming Cow sets itself apart with bold flavors and a smooth, rich texture. The price reflects the care in farming and the high quality of each small batch.

6. Alexandre Family Farm Yogurt

Alexandre Family Farm is known for its organic, A2/A2 yogurt that some people find easier to digest. They make whole milk and Greek-style yogurts with a rich, creamy texture. A 24-ounce container costs between $6 and $8. Their milk comes from cows on regenerative farms that help the environment.

This type of farming also supports healthy soil and reduces carbon in the air. The yogurts are free from antibiotics, GMOs, and artificial hormones. They come in plain, vanilla, and strawberry. People who care about health, the planet, and great taste find this brand worth the higher price.

7. Peak Yogurt—Triple Cream Luxury

Peak Yogurt offers a super-rich Triple Cream yogurt with 17% milk fat, one of the highest on the market. Each small cup costs between $3.50 and $5.00. It’s made for people following keto or low-carb diets who still want a creamy, satisfying treat. Its thick texture and gentle flavor make it perfect for both sweet and savory recipes.

Peak uses grass-fed milk and adds probiotics to support digestion. The yogurt contains no added sugars or artificial ingredients. It comes in flavors like vanilla and strawberry, with special seasonal options. For those wanting indulgence without guilt, it’s a top pick.

8. Straus Family Creamery Organic Yogurt

Straus Family Creamery has been a leader in organic dairy, offering both Greek and European-style yogurts. A 32-ounce container costs between $6 and $9. Their yogurts are made in small batches with milk from pasture-raised cows. They don’t homogenize the milk, so a natural cream layer forms on top.

The result is a smooth, tangy yogurt that feels rich. Their yogurts come in plain, vanilla, and lemon gingersnap flavors. The brand uses reusable glass jars, which add to their appeal. Health and eco-conscious shoppers love Straus for its flavor and ethical farming methods.

9. Redwood Hill Farm Goat Milk Yogurt

Redwood Hill Farm makes goat milk yogurt for those with cow milk allergies or those wanting something new. A 6-ounce cup costs around $3.00 to $4.00, with larger tubs priced higher. The yogurt is made in small batches from milk from family-run farms. Goat milk is easier to digest and gives the yogurt a tangy, earthy flavor.

The company uses clean, ethical farming methods and avoids GMOs and synthetic additives. Common flavors include vanilla, blueberry, and plain. Its rich texture and health benefits make it a great option for those wanting something different in the yogurt aisle.

10. Saint Benoît Creamery Yogurt

Saint Benoît Creamery makes luxurious whole-milk yogurt using traditional French methods. Each 4-ounce glass jar costs about $3.50 to $5.00. The yogurt is made from organic Jersey cow milk, known for being rich and golden. Only natural ingredients are used—no thickeners or preservatives.

The elegant, eco-friendly packaging adds to the brand’s appeal. Their small batches and pure ingredients create a truly rich, creamy product. Flavors include Vanilla, Strawberry, and special types like Meyer Lemon. Gourmet food fans and people who want a natural, decadent dairy experience often choose this yogurt despite its premium price.

11. Traderspoint Creamery Whole Milk Yogurt

Traderspoint Creamery makes premium whole milk yogurt from 100% grass-fed cows. It comes in sizes from 5-ounce to 32-ounce glass containers. A small cup can cost between $3.00 and $4.50, with larger tubs priced even higher. This Indiana-based family creamery uses sustainable farming and avoids synthetic additives.

Their slow fermentation process gives the yogurt a thick texture and tangy flavor. Popular flavors include Wildberry, Mango, and Plain. The yogurt is also organic and packed with live cultures for digestive health. Often found in farmer’s markets or specialty stores, this brand offers quality and taste that stands out.

12. Ellenos Real Greek Yogurt

Ellenos is a Greek-style yogurt brand from Seattle known for its dessert-like creaminess. A single cup can cost between $4.00 and $6.00. The yogurt is made with whole milk and a secret family recipe that gives it a cheesecake-like texture. Flavors include Passion Fruit, Lemon Curd, and Marionberry, along with seasonal options like Pumpkin Pie.

Each batch is handmade daily and has a short shelf life to ensure freshness. The brand uses real ingredients and avoids shortcuts. Found in gourmet shops and markets, Ellenos offers a rich, indulgent experience that many say is worth every penny.

13. The Greek Gods Greek Yogurt

The Greek Gods brand offers a full-fat yogurt known for its creamy texture and bold taste. A 24-ounce tub costs between $4.00 and $7.00. Unlike many brands that push low-fat options, Greek Gods embraces the richness of full-fat dairy. Their yogurts include unique flavors like Fig, Honey Vanilla, and Honey Strawberry.

They use real fruit and natural sweeteners to enhance taste. It’s also full of probiotics for digestive support. Though sold at many big stores, its quality and flavor make it feel like a specialty product. For those wanting rich, flavorful yogurt, this brand is a favorite.

Even though yogurt is a common food in the US, these premium options show it can be more than just a healthy snack. From rich flavors to careful farming, each brand offers something special. These high-end yogurts show how ingredients and effort turn a simple item into something luxurious.

Whether you’re ready to buy or just curious, exploring these products gives insight into how quality and care make a difference. Yogurt can be more than breakfast—it can be an experience of taste and well-being.

FAQs

Last Thought

Luxury yogurts show how quality and care can turn an everyday item into something special. Whether it’s grass-fed milk, rare fruit flavors, or eco-friendly packaging, each detail adds value. These brands may cost more, but they deliver in taste, health, and ethical standards.

Exploring these yogurts helps you see how food can be both indulgent and good for you. For those who seek more from their dairy, these top-tier yogurts offer a delicious way to upgrade your routine.